36 Queen Street, London, EC4R 1BN | +44 (0)20 7242 2642
Jaggers v. Ellis (Chancery Division)

Income tax. Schedule D. Farming / woodlands.

The taxpayer grew Christmas trees. On a nine-acre site, coniferous trees were planted: mainly Norway Spruce, but also two other species not normally grown in woodlands. The trees were young and more closely spaced than they would have been if grown for forestry purposes. They were specially pruned to give a Christmas tree shape. The Special Commissioner found as a fact that the land was not “woodlands”.

The taxpayer was assessed under Schedule D on the deemed trade under s.53(3) ICTA 1988. The taxpayer argued that the land she occupied was “woodlands” within the meaning of s.53(4) ICTA 1988, in which case she was exempted from the provisions of s.53(3).

Held: The Special Commissioner’s finding of fact was not irrational. The word “woodlands” fell to be interpreted according to its normal English usage, and the Special Commissioner (who had viewed the site) could not be said to have been irrational in deciding that the site was not “woodlands”, even though it was a site on which trees were grown.

Aparna Nathan appeared for the taxpayer

Latest news:

Gray’s Inn Tax Chambers is delighted to have been shortlisted for 4 separate awards at The Legal 500 Bar Awards 2023
19 Jul 2023
GITC is sad to report the death of our Head of Chambers, Mr Milton Grundy who passed away at the weekend.
Gray’s Inn Tax Chambers is deeply saddened by the passing of our founding member and Head of Chambers, Mr Milton Grundy
28 Nov 2022
GITC Review
The 2022 GITC Review is now available
If you would like to be added to the mailing list for future issues of the GITC Review, please send an email to Jane.Fullbrook@taxbar.com.
Read review